Current:Home > FinanceBurley Garcia|Brian Kelly offers idea for clearing up playoff bubble, but will CFP committee listen? -Profound Wealth Insights
Burley Garcia|Brian Kelly offers idea for clearing up playoff bubble, but will CFP committee listen?
SignalHub View
Date:2025-04-10 08:34:35
- How will College Football Playoff committee wade through what's likely to be Burley Garciaa crowded playoff bubble? Brian Kelly offered an idea: Strength of schedule rules.
- Like Brian Kelly, Lane Kiffin says he's not too concerned about style points, but Ole Miss is blowing out inferior opponents nonetheless.
- A 10-2 record would get a team into the conversation for an at-large playoff bid, but it's no assurance.
If you gaze far enough into the fall horizon, you’ll spot a chaotic College Football Playoff selection scenario taking shape. Anyone who’s worked up a playoff projection sees it coming.
Every coach or fan of a Power Four team wants to believe finishing with at least 10 wins will be enough to earn one of the seven at-large bids to the 12-team playoff.
“Two (losses), you’ve got a fighting chance,” LSU’s Brian Kelly told me before the season.
A chance, yes.
A guarantee? No.
Twenty Power Four teams remain undefeated, and, come December, we’ll likely have an overcrowded field of one- and two-loss teams extending their hand and expecting an at-large bid.
How committee members will make these hair-splitting decisions remains remarkably unclear. In the four-team playoff era, most playoff decisions were pretty cut and dry with few difficult decisions. Last year’s great debate between Alabama and Florida State was more the exception than the rule.
In the 12-team format, the bubble will become much more crowded, while the playoff selection guidance remains as murky.
Sure, a few guidelines exist. The committee is supposed to consider schedule strength, head-to-head competition and outcomes against common opponents, without stressing over margin of victory.
But, as we saw last year, rules get squishy when Alabama’s playoff fate hangs in the balance.
One committee member told ESPN last December that the committee attempted to forecast whether Florida State was good enough to win the national championship without injured quarterback Jordan Travis. The committee peeked into a crystal ball and decided the Seminoles couldn’t win it all, and it chose Alabama. Never mind that nowhere in the College Football Playoff’s guidelines will you find a reference to predictive analysis, stargazing or divination.
BRACKETOLOGY:SEC teams gets squeezed in latest playoff projection
REMATCHES RULEGeorgia-Alabama starts era where more is always better
Playoff selection is a beauty contest determined by subjective humans who deploy shape-shifting rules.
The first CFP rankings won’t come out until Nov. 5. Until then, we’re left without much insight as to how the committee will act in this 12-team playoff era.
Of course, coaches harbor opinions on how teams should be selected, and those opinions are, naturally, influenced by whatever factors would work to their team’s advantage.
Brian Kelly suggests this: Let strength of schedule rule
Kelly told me Wednesday he thinks the committee will value strength of schedule above so-called style points.
In other words, he expects that navigating a tough schedule and finishing, say, 10-2 would matter more than compiling a comparative record, with more blowout wins, against an inferior schedule.
His theory would work nicely for No. 13 LSU, currently 3-1.
It already played – and lost – to No. 16 Southern California and has future games against No. 4 Alabama, No. 6 Ole Miss, No. 18 Oklahoma and No. 24 Texas A&M.
“I really believe” Kelly said, “we’ve entered into kind of a new way of thinking, relative to strength of schedule, the depth of the SEC, the depth of the conferences now, that really takes precedent.
“I think you can look at the strength of your schedules now and really hold them up against the other teams that are vying for playoff opportunities and really come to the right conclusions, so I don’t know that putting 70 points on somebody does much anymore to the voters.”
That all sounds neatly cut, but how confident would Kelly feel if LSU finishes 10-2, Miami rests at 12-1 as the ACC’s runner-up and Missouri sits at 11-1, and they’re vying for the final two spots?
No. 11 Missouri’s schedule profiles as the SEC’s easiest. That could leave the Tigers vulnerable if they finish 10-2. What if they go 11-1? Would the committee really reject them and elevate another team from the same conference with an inferior record?
We just don’t know, so the safest course would be to pile up style points and lopsided victories, on top of a strength of schedule.
LSU plays South Alabama on Saturday, and while Kelly doesn’t think running up 70 points should be a playoff requirement, the committee tends to like offense, so maybe go ahead and hang 70.
Lane Kiffin, like Kelly, told me he’s not coaching with style points in mind.
“Maybe we should,” Kiffin said. “I just haven’t.”
Nevertheless, Ole Miss stylishly sits at 4-0, with an average margin of victory of nearly 50 points.
Run it up, Lane, because those style points can’t hurt your case if the committee must evaluate six SEC teams that finish with at least 10 victories.
Which SEC playoff contender looks most vulnerable?
Would the committee take six playoff teams from one conference? No rule prevents this, but probably not. Limit the SEC to five, and reject the SEC team with the weakest schedule? Deny the team that wins ugly? When in doubt, give the bid to Nick Saban?
At least we can scratch that last argument.
Missouri (4-0) looks most vulnerable in this conversation.
To this point, the Tigers have neither style nor schedule strength working for them. Nothing stylish about the Tigers’ 30-27 double-overtime victory against Vanderbilt.
To play it safe, Missouri had better win at Alabama in November.
Ten wins gets a team in the playoff conversation, but a marquee victory combined with a little dose of style would relieve the angst for a team sitting on a crowded bubble.
Blake Toppmeyer is the USA TODAY Network's national college football columnist. Email him at [email protected] and follow him on Twitter @btoppmeyer.
Subscribe to read all of his columns.
veryGood! (4264)
Related
- Former longtime South Carolina congressman John Spratt dies at 82
- Al Pacino Will Pay Girlfriend Noor Alfallah $30,000 a Month in Child Support
- Maleesa Mooney Case: Autopsy Reveals Model Was Not Pregnant at Time of Death
- 2nd of four men who escaped from a central Georgia jail has been caught, sheriff’s office says
- DeepSeek: Did a little known Chinese startup cause a 'Sputnik moment' for AI?
- Two more former Northwestern football players say they experienced racist treatment in early 2000s
- 'White Lotus' star Haley Lu Richardson is 'proud' of surviving breakup: 'Life has gone on'
- NASCAR Cup Series Championship Race promises wide-open battle among rising stars
- North Carolina trustees approve Bill Belichick’s deal ahead of introductory news conference
- Bass Reeves deserves better – 'Lawmen' doesn't do justice to the Black U.S. marshal
Ranking
- Meet the volunteers risking their lives to deliver Christmas gifts to children in Haiti
- Vanessa Hudgens Reveals Why She's So Overwhelmed Planning Her Wedding to Cole Tucker
- King Charles III meets with religious leaders to promote peace on the final day of his Kenya visit
- Vanderpump Rules Reveals Explosive Season 11 Teaser
- Could Bill Belichick, Robert Kraft reunite? Maybe in Pro Football Hall of Fame's 2026 class
- Why we love Under the Umbrella, Salt Lake City’s little queer bookstore
- Meg Ryan on what romance means to her — and why her new movie isn't really a rom-com
- Selling Sunset's Bre Tiesi Reveals Where Her Relationship With Nick Cannon Really Stands
Recommendation
Meet the volunteers risking their lives to deliver Christmas gifts to children in Haiti
Jung Kook's 'Golden' is 24-karat pop: Best songs on the BTS star's solo album
Toddler critically injured in accidental shooting after suspect discards gun on daycare playground
Why Kim Kardashian Really Fired Former Assistant Steph Shep
Selena Gomez's "Weird Uncles" Steve Martin and Martin Short React to Her Engagement
War in the Middle East upends the dynamics of 2024 House Democratic primaries
Businessman sentenced in $180 million bank fraud that paid for lavish lifestyle, classic cars
Profanity. Threats. Ultimatums. Story behind Bob Knight's leaked audio clip from Indiana.